
I adore hand cream. I hoard hand cream. I hoard almost anything in a little tube, but hand cream is my passion. Because I’ve horribly ugly hands, and I detest using gloves. My hands are usually scratched, burnt, scarred (from childhood misadventures and kitchen gaffes) and dry.
Anyway, I thought it’d be a good way to start this off. A hand cream face off.
What makes a good hand cream?
For me, it’s texture. I like it a little creamier, and consequently a little oilier. I enjoy the odd light runny one now and then, but my skin is mostly dry and appreciates a little heavier handling. Secondarily, it’s after-feel and fragrance. I suppose I should factor things like cost and packaging in there somewhere too.
Getting to itand in some particular order (it’s in alphabetical order of company name, silly!)
Aveeno Active Naturals Intense Relief Hand Cream with Natural Colloidal Oatmeal
Texture: suprisingly balanced. Sort of like a moussey-serum. It spreads and absorbs well, and dries very quickly. It certainly does provide relief to my overwashed hands. Does little for my cuticles though.
After-feel: not greasy at all, though it can leave my palms a little sticky. Top of the hand feels like it’s clean but moisturised.
Fragrance: no fragrance. Fragrance-free.
Packaging: Inverted tube (my favourite kind). Nothing fancy.
My rating: 4 / 5
My verdict: hands down, my favourite drugstore hand cream. It does get a little boring – I like my hands to smell clean, not like soy. I used to use this at work with a heavier hand cream at night, but now that I’m at home, I’m trying to use up the stash of little tubes I’ve got so I haven’t used it for a while.
Bath and Body Work’s Look Ma, New Hands
Texture: a little on the heavy side, the way I like it. It spreads and absorbs well. It leaves my hands soft (right until I wash it again, which is, when I’m at home, probably 20 minutes later). I like rubbing it in my cuticles, it keeps them soft.
After-feel: is a little greasy up to 5 minutes after application. It usually dries in 10, but I end up wiping the excess on my jeans after a few minutes. It’s greasy enough to leave marks on any smooth surface and paper.
Fragrance: nice citrusy-grapefruit scent going on. I like it. It’s fresh and light.
Packaging: I bought a blob (short and fat) of a tube to toss about in my bag, so that works for me. I have a feeling though, with the material of a larger tube, you’re going to end up with a pretty smudgey tube.
My rating: 2.5 / 5
My verdict: I’m on the fence on this one. I like that it makes my hands feel soft, but it takes forever to degrease. The handcream junkie I am, I’d probably have it lying about somewhere for variety. But it’s not in my top 3.
Bliss High Intensity Hand Cream
Texture: nicely balanced. Not pasty, but nice and smooth. It spreads like margarine though, very very smoothly. It stays on my hands, and keeps my cuticles happy as well. Dries quickly, doesn’t leave a greasy film on hands.
After-feel: hands feel taken care of. Keeps the tops of my hands moisturised without leaving my palms greasy and sticky. Survives a light wash most of the time.
Fragrance: my favourite of the lot. Smells like Bliss’ Lemon + Sage line of products. It’s citrusy, clean and happy. Lovesit.
Packaging: Another little trial tube that went in a handbag but ended up getting used up too quickly. Too bad it doesn’t come in standing bottle with pump. I’d use this all day!
My rating: 4.5 / 5
My verdict: Favourite all-round hand cream. Love the way it smells and most importantly it works well on my hands. Might be a little on the heavy side for normal / better looked after hands. Wonder if they make a Blood Orange scented version, I’d try that in a snap!
Body Shop Almond Oil Daily Hand & Nail Cream 3.4 Oz.
Texture: a little liquidy. It certainly spread on well, but it took a while to absorb. I used to use this in the office, and my keyboard was all sticky from residue of this hand cream, mostly because it took too long to dry. Doesn’t really do anything for my cuticles. I could’ve used less, but then my hands didn’t feel taken care of enough.
After-feel: nothing to call home about. Made my hands a little sticky too.
Fragrance: nice almondy scent, but artificially so.
Packaging: I bought the tube version, but I think it comes in a standy pump.
My rating: 1 / 5
My verdict: I bought this because I was a die-hard Body Shop fan, but this really isn’t one of their pride and joys. Highly ignorable.
Burt’s Bees Beeswax and Banana Hand Creme, 2-Ounce Jar
Texture: super rich is a good description! This was almost like the texture of hair wax – it has a mind of its own! It probably doesn’t help that I don’t live in the tropics anymore. Very sticky, very greasy. I slather this on at night, wear a pair of cotton gloves and hope my skin and not the cotton absorbs it.
Fragrance: very banana-y. Not in a great way. It smells as heavy and rich as it feels. Not a big fan. It’s like a dense banana cake smell, not the light fragrance of fresh banana.
After-feel: you’ll be sliding off everything you touch, so you won’t really be feeling much.
Packaging: that it came in a jar should’ve given me a clue. But then again, I liked the jar. It’s cute. I like jars.
My rating: 1.5 / 5 (because I do use it at night)
My verdict: One of those I can do without. Not sure if their Almond Milk Beeswax version will fare better, but I’m sure it’ll smell better.
Ok. This post has taken me longer than I can bear in 1 sitting, and I’ve still got to a few more creams to cover. I’ll leave that in a later post, since those are some of my favourites.